Skip to Content

Blue Marlin Motel Demolition Begins in Wildwood Crest

Blue Marlin Motel Demolition Begins in Wildwood Crest

Another chapter in Wildwood Crest’s motel history is coming to an end as demolition begins at the former Blue Marlin Motel.

Located at 401 East Toledo Avenue, the corner of Toledo and Atlantic avenues, the two-story property was a familiar sight for generations of visitors.

Blue Marlin Motel Demolition Begins in Wildwood Crest

Blue Marlin Motel Demolition Begins in Wildwood Crest

Now, crews have started demolishing the motel, marking the latest change to the Crest’s landscape as older Doo-Wop motel properties make way for residential development.

The property’s future has been moving in that direction for some time.

You may recall that last year the Wildwood Video Archive reported that the Wildwood Crest Planning Board approved an application by 401 Toledo Avenue, LLC, seeking minor subdivision approval and variance relief for the site.

The redevelopment proposal called for dividing the motel property into three residential lots for single-family homes.

This is something we were expecting as the original listing for proposed Lot 1.03 at 401 East Toledo Avenue carried an asking price of $1.55 million with the listing describes a beach-block building opportunity with potential water views and space for a single-family home, pool and cabana.

Also See: Carini’s Restaurant in Wildwood Crest Closing After 41 Years

It also stated that the property would be cleared before settlement. Well that clearing is happening right now.

While many visitors remember the building as the Blue Marlin, its more recent identity was connected to another longtime Crest motel.

In May 2023, Ala Kai Motel owner Jay Maher acquired the neighboring Blue Marlin and announced that both properties would operate under the Ala Kai umbrella. At the time, the plan was to maintain motel accommodations across the two buildings, with guests having access to both swimming pools. The former Blue Marlin subsequently appeared in real estate listings as Ala Kai II.

With demolition now underway, attention turns to the next stage of the property’s redevelopment. A construction start date for the proposed homes has not been confirmed.

As the years roll on down here in the Wildwoods, we are slowly losing our identity as a shore destination built around neon signs, colorful motels, and family traditions passed down through generations. These buildings helped make our island recognizable. For so many visitors, returning to the same motel each summer was as much a part of their vacation as walking the boardwalk or spending a day on the beach.

We understand that properties age, maintenance costs rise, and owners face difficult decisions. But every time another classic motel comes down, we lose another piece of the character that made the Wildwoods special. New homes can fill the lot, but they cannot replace the memories, the history, or the feeling of pulling up to a familiar neon sign and knowing your summer vacation had officially begun.

The Wildwood Video Archive will be sure to stop by this week to film the progress on the demo.

Photos by Dan Robinson

Before you watch our latest video below, please consider subscribing.